Thursday, December 01, 2011

God or Religion - what takes precedence?

I found this article particularly insightful and compelling, not least in light of the internal debates here in Israel over various religious issues (not mentioned below).  I’m not weighing in on the US presidential candidates but certainly do agree with the fundamental principle here: religion is meant to serve God and/or a higher purpose, and clearly is distorted when it seems to become MORE important than God or those moral values it is meant to promote.  Or as he puts it, “the religious fanatic is the man or woman who has ceased to serve God and instead worships his or her religion…”.

-----------------

Are Mormons any weirder than the rest of us?
By SHMULEY BOTEACH
28/11/2011

I don't believe Joseph Smith found ancient tablets in upstate New York. What has that got to do with electing politicians?


I have been close to Mormons ever since my days at Oxford, when Michael Taft Benson became a member and then an elected officer of our L’Chaim Society at the University. Benson’s grandfather, Ezra Taft Benson, was the prophet of the Mormon Church at the time. Thus began a lifelong friendship that continues till today, with many visits to lecture for Mike at Southern Utah University and other mostly Mormon academies of higher learning in the majority Mormon state.

I have thus watched with mild amusement as the debate surrounding the beliefs of Mitt Romney and Jon Huntsman have gained steam. Aren’t the Mormons weird fanatics? Should we trust people with such strange beliefs with high office? 

This is an interesting question coming from my evangelical brothers and sisters whose belief that a man, born of a virgin, was the son of God, only to die on a cross, and then be resurrected. With all due respect, that’s not exactly the most rational belief, either.

The criticisms are equally interesting coming from Orthodox Jews, like myself, who believe that the Red Sea split, a donkey talked to Balaam, and the sun stood still for Joshua.

But it is equally strange coming from evolutionists like Richard Dawkins who have said, without a single shred of evidence, that life on our planet may have been seeded by space aliens. Even those evolutionists who reject Dawkins’ faith in extraterrestrial life have a belief system of their own; namely, that intelligent life somehow evolved capriciously and accidentally from inorganic matter, even though the possibility of complex organisms evolving without guidance is mathematically nearly impossible.

Julian Huxley, who stemmed from the world’s most famous family of evolutionary proponents, described the probability of the evolution of a horse thus: “A proportion of favorable mutations of one-ina- thousand does not sound much, but is probably generous... and a total of a million mutational steps sounds a great deal, but is probably an understatement....With this proportion, we should clearly have to breed a million strains (a thousand squared) to get one containing two favorable mutations, and so on, up to a thousand to the millionth power to get one containing a million.... No one would bet on anything so improbable happening...and yet it has happened!” 

Yes, even men of science can believe things that can be construed as highly irrational.

NOW, DO believe that Joseph Smith found ancient tablets written in reformed Egyptian in upstate New York, that Jesus Christ appeared to the people of South America as recorded in the book of Mormon, or that when a Mormon dies he becomes a god and gets his own planet? No. Respectfully, I do not. Nor should it matter. It is what a person does, rather than what they believe, that counts. It took four years for the Dalai Lama to be identified as the reincarnation of his predecessor in a process that to Western eyes can appear highly arbitrary. Yet, the Dalai Lama remains one of the most respected men alive because of his commitment to world peace and good works.

Misguided attacks on groups like the Mormons stem from a willful desire on the part of many to fraudulently identify people with a different faith system as fanatics. Therefore, a brief discussion of religious fundamentalism is in order.

The most confusing story of the Bible involves God’s commandment to Abraham to sacrifice his son Isaac. What was the God who would later declare that all human, and especially child sacrifice, to be an abomination, thinking?

The most insightful commentary I have seen on this story comes from the Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Menachem Schneerson, who said that the key to the story is to see Isaac not as an individual but as a religion. Who was Isaac? He was Judaism. He was the person who would continue Abraham’s belief system. With his death, everything that Abraham had taught in terms of his rejection of paganism and the belief in one God would be lost.

The test, therefore, was this: would Abraham follow God’s commandment to kill off his religion or would he put his religion before God’s will? What really mattered to Abraham? God, or Judaism? And if they were to be put in conflict, what would he choose? The religious fanatic is the man or woman who has ceased to serve God and instead worships his or her religion, turning their faith into yet another false idol. Religion is solely the means by which by which we come to have a relationship with our Creator. But when it becomes a substitute for God it becomes soulless and fanatical, seeing as there is no loving deity to temper it.

In this light we can understand why an Islamic fundamentalist is so deadly, prepared even to go against God’s express commandment not to murder. He is prepared to kill not in order to strike a blow for the glory of God, but of Islam.

Hence, our concern need not be with a person’s faith in public office. It does not matter if they are Jewish, evangelical, Mormon, or Muslim. What does matter is whether their faith is focused on relating to God and, by extension, caring for God’s children. Do they see the purpose of their high station being to promote their particular religion? 

It is easy to identify the difference. People who are in a relationship with God are humble and do their utmost to refrain from judging others. Their proximity to a Perfect Being reminds them of their own fallibility, and their experience of God’s compassion leads them to be merciful and loving.

In contrast, those who worship a religion are arrogant and think they have the only truth. They are dismissive of other people’s beliefs and maintain that advancing the cause of their religion is more important than life itself. The Israeli rabbi who recently made the strange comment that soldiers should choose a firing squad rather than listen to a woman sing is a classic example of this heresy.
Those who worship religion evince the classic characteristic of cult members. Whereas a real faith system is empowering and makes one strong and capable of operating outside their own faith community, cult members can only identify with other members of their group and require the environment of the cult in order to function. They don’t have beliefs. Rather, they take orders.

I see none of these characteristics in Mitt Romney or Jon Huntsman – who graciously hosted me along with my guest Elie Wiesel at the governor’s mansion in Utah a few years back – or any of my countless other Mormon friends. All should be judged on their merits as people and politicians, whatever their faith and whatever their beliefs.

The writer has just published of Ten Conversations You Need to Have with Yourself, (Wiley), and will shortly publish Kosher Jesus. Follow him on his website www.shmuley.com and on Twitter @RabbiShmuley.

18 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

nice posting.. thanks for sharing.

3:17 AM  
Blogger Johanes Brian said...

http://johanesbrian.blogspot.com/

5:30 PM  
Blogger Johanes Brian said...

thanks for indo

5:30 PM  
Blogger the publisher said...

Thanks for your grateful informations, am working in, asian affairs news magazine.
Try to post best informations like this always
Middle East: The Israeli periphery

8:11 AM  
Blogger Nethmi Fernando said...

thnkzzzz & visit me

Nawayugaya Downloads Zone
www.nawayugaya.wordpress.com

AeekSoft Downloads Zone
www.aeeksoft.blogspot.com

HD Wallpapers Pack Free Download
www.oeekwallpapers.blogspot.com

Live Cam Chat Rooms
www.webcamfire.com

5:55 PM  
Blogger Encounters Nepal said...

Encounters Nepal Dot Com is an ethically governed and environmentally aware Trekking & Adventure Tour Operator. The company exists to promote and share with others the diverse geographical beauty as well as the cultural wealth of our homeland, Nepal, as well as that of some of our neighbours, such as Tibet and Bhutan. Predominantly, it is the mighty Himalayan ranges that attract visitors from all over the world to Nepal. Upon arrival, guests to our country are then also captivated by the interplay of the majestic mountainous landscapes with the overriding hospitality of the Nepali people. Our rich spiritual life and our many vibrantly joyous customs are born of the melding of the Hindu and Buddhist cultures which have co existed here side by side for centuries. This adds a mystical dimension to most travelers’ experiences in Nepal. It is this interplay of magnificent landscapes, of friendly and welcoming people from many different ethnic backgrounds and the complex, beautiful overlay of religious rites and cultural practices that make a sojourn in Nepal.
Trekking in Nepal
Everest Base Camp Trekking
Annapurna Circuit trekking
Upper Dolpo trekking
Manaslu Circuit trekking
Kanchenjunga base camp Trekking
Mansarovar Kailash Shiva Parbat Yatra

1:45 PM  
Blogger TrekNp said...

Welcome to Buna Treks
BUNA "The Best & Unique Nepal Adventure" Company was founded by a group of dynamic Nepalese Tourism Professionals. This company has led countless adventures throughout various Himalayan destinations, which have included India, Tibet and Bhutan. With two decades of experience of organizing adventure trekking, and leisure trips tailor-made for families, schools and corporate executives, we can offer you quality equipment, excellent food that will add harmony in your Himalayan adventure
Trekking in Nepal
Trekking Company in Nepal
Everest base camp trekking
Annapurna base camp trekking
Manaslu Circuit trekking
Upper mustang trekking
Kangjunga trekking
Annapurna Circuit Trekking

10:44 AM  
Blogger TrekNp said...

Welcome to Buna Treks
BUNA "The Best & Unique Nepal Adventure" Company was founded by a group of dynamic Nepalese Tourism Professionals. This company has led countless adventures throughout various Himalayan destinations, which have included India, Tibet and Bhutan. With two decades of experience of organizing adventure trekking, and leisure trips tailor-made for families, schools and corporate executives, we can offer you quality equipment, excellent food that will add harmony in your Himalayan adventure
Trekking in Nepal
Trekking Company in Nepal
Everest base camp trekking
Annapurna base camp trekking
Manaslu Circuit trekking
Upper mustang trekking
Kangjunga trekking
Annapurna Circuit Trekking

10:44 AM  
Blogger Sappa Tamang said...

Namaste and welcome to Nepal Base Camp Treks!!!

Nepal Base Camp Treks is one of the best trekking agencies in Nepal. We operate fantastic trekking, mountaineering, peak climbing, jungle safari and tours packages in various must-go tourist destinations of Nepal and our neighboring countries Bhutan and Tibet. So, don’t bother searching for a reliable and excellent trekking operator in Nepal coz Nepal Base Camp Treks Pvt. Ltd. is already with you.
Everest Base Camp Treks
Trekking in Nepal
Trekking Company in Nepal
Annapurna base camp Treks
Manaslu circuit trek
Everest trekking
Annapurna circuit Treks
Langtang Valley Trekking
Upper Mustang Trekking
Kanchanjunga Trekking
Trekking Guide in Nepal
Peak Climbing in Nepal
Package tour in Nepal

5:51 AM  
Blogger Sappa Tamang said...

Namaste and welcome to Nepal Base Camp Treks!!!

Nepal Base Camp Treks is one of the best trekking agencies in Nepal. We operate fantastic trekking, mountaineering, peak climbing, jungle safari and tours packages in various must-go tourist destinations of Nepal and our neighboring countries Bhutan and Tibet. So, don’t bother searching for a reliable and excellent trekking operator in Nepal coz Nepal Base Camp Treks Pvt. Ltd. is already with you.
Everest Base Camp Treks
Trekking in Nepal
Trekking Company in Nepal
Annapurna base camp Treks
Manaslu circuit trek
Everest trekking
Annapurna circuit Treks
Langtang Valley Trekking
Upper Mustang Trekking
Kanchanjunga Trekking
Trekking Guide in Nepal
Peak Climbing in Nepal
Package tour in Nepal

7:38 AM  
Blogger Ankur said...

Nice,

Thanks for your greatful informations, working in, ASIAN AFFAIRS MAGAZINE.

Try to post best informations like this always

Middle East : Israel and Hamas shy away from peace talks

8:24 AM  
Blogger Rabin Gurung said...

Adventure Mountain Guide Team has been a leader in providing high country Travels and adventure activities Trekking in Nepal, 'www.adventuremountainguide.net' organizes Adventure Trekking, Peak Climbing, Package tours and river rafting for groups and individuals from all walks of life. We can assure that flexible design any program or package to suit your interest, schedule, fitness level and budget travels Service. Our highly experienced and professional Working team will be always ready to provide you the best of all trekking and tours services in Nepal.
Trekking in Nepal
Trekking Guide in Nepal
Everest Base Camp Trekking
Annapurna base camp trekking
Manaslu Circuit Trekking
Upper Mustang Trekking
Kanchanjunga trekking
Upper Dolpo Trekking
Ghorepani Poonhill Trekking
Langtang Valley Trekking
Peak Climbing in Nepal
Island Peak Climbing
Mera Peak Climbing
Annapurna Circuit Trekking

7:37 PM  
Blogger Web Master said...

Adventure Great Himalaya is a government registered Trekking company in Nepal. comprised of qualified and experienced professional Nepal Trekking Agency. Adventure Great Himalaya has provided thousands of high quality trekking and tours trips for clients from all over the world. If your interest lies in Trekking In Nepal, Peak climbing, Tours in Nepal and River rafting or cultural sightseeing, our professional and knowledgeable staff is available to make your stay comfortable and memorable. Leave your worries to us and enjoy your holidays in Nepal.
trekking company in Nepal
Trekking Agency in Nepal
Trekking in Nepal
Everest base camp trek
Annapurna base camp trek
manaslu Circuit Trekking
Peak Climbing in Nepal
Langtang Valley Trek
Upper Mustang
Kanchanjunga Trekking

12:03 PM  
Blogger Web Master said...

Adventure Trek Nepal Paradise Trekking Guide Co-operitive has been a leader in providing high country Travels and adventure activities Trekking in Nepal, Tibet, 'Treknp.com' organizes Trekking Peak , hiking, tours and river rafting for groups and individuals from all walks of life. We can assure that flexible design any program or package to suit your interest, schedule, fitness level and budget travels Service. Our organizing skills are as flexible as the mountains we escort you to.
Trekking in Nepal
Trekking company in nepal
Everest Base Camp Trekking
Annapurna base Camp Trekking
Ghorepani Poonhill trekking
manaslu Circuit trekking
Upper Mustang Trekking
Mera Peak Climbing
Island Peak Climbing
Langtang Valley Trekking
Package tour in Nepal

9:58 AM  
Blogger Eva Andressa said...

Langtang Region

This trek will take you into some of the wildest and most scenic areas of Nepal from the fertile rice basins of Trisuli to the dense forests of rhododendron and conifer on the higher slopes, the high alpine Yak pastures, glaciers and moraines around Kyangin Gompa. The remote holy lakes at Gosainkunda along the route we experience the whole range of Himalayan topography.


The area, lies in the Himalayan National Park and still relatively undisturbed, supports a healthy population of wildlife and there are good chance of seeing various species of wild goat and deer, possibly even better. Bird and botanical life are equally impressive, all set against the backdrop of the magnificent mountains.

Popular Treks In the Lantang Region

09 days Langtang Valley Trek

08 days Helambu Circuit Trek

16 days Langtang Gosainkund Trek

15 days Tamang Heritage Trek
Langtang Regions trekking

Annapurna region trek and hiking
Everest regions trekking hiking
Peak in Nepal
http://www.nepalguideinfo.com/Langtang-Valley-Trek.php

8:05 AM  
Blogger Boundless Adventure said...

Trekking in Nepal is delighted to welcome to you tiny but amazing country in Nepal. When you will have boundless adventures, there are attraction sharing and memorable in your life. Nepal trekking company, found by the team of enthusiastic and the trekking specialists is devoted to impart you a fondest memory during your Nepal holiday with us. We have been serving not here in Nepal only, also in Tibet, India and Bhutan as well. No matter, what type of trip you choose in Nepal. Either Nepal trekking, rafting and cannoning, Nepal Tour , mountaineering, Nepal Peak Climbing , jungle safaris and Nepal trekking activities. Nepal traveling with us is more than just a brief to stay somewhere; it is a real connection with the people, the unique countryside, distinctive culture, the Nepali cuisine, the environment and the flora and fauna of the country. Nepal tea house trekking offering for small trekking groups and big trekking groups. We are offering you, as your choice trekking service as well. You will find out our Nepal trekking guide will be the warm hospitality and government trended license to lead the Nepal historical place And Nepal Himalayan ranges .
For more details click on the below links:
Trekking in Nepal
Nepal Trekking
Everest Trekking
Everest Base Camp Trekking
Annapurna Trekking
Langtang Valley Trekking
Mustang Trekking
Manaslu Trekking
Nepal Hiking
Nepal Tour
Nepal Helicopter tour
Nepal Peak Climbing
Everest Three Pass Trekking

3:02 PM  
Blogger Dharel Ajay said...

Welcome you all to World Sight Journey, a Nepal-based travel operator offering world class trekking and touring services!
Established a decade ago, World Sight Journey has been specializing in providing premier trekking, expeditions, and touring packages in the various hotspot destinations of Nepal. Besides, we also have been organizing hiking, jungle safari, river rafting, bungee jumping and mountain biking packages successfully throughout the popular destinations of Nepal. Since the inception, World Sight Journey has been proudly showcasing the scenic beauty of glorious Himalayas, the grandeur of incredibly diverse and wonderful Nepalese culture, amazingly rich flora and fauna, some yet-to-be discovered landscapes and many more to its valued clients from around the globe. We are so proud to showcase Nepal to the world.
trekking in Nepal, Trekking Company in Nepal, Everest base camp Trekking, Annapurna Base Camp Trekking, Upper Mustang Trekking , Peak Climbing in Nepal, Manaslu Circuit Trekking, Kanchenjunga Trekking, Island Peak Climbing

5:13 AM  
Blogger Dharel Ajay said...

Welcome you all to World Sight Journey, a Nepal-based travel operator offering world class trekking and touring services!
Established a decade ago, World Sight Journey has been specializing in providing premier trekking, expeditions, and touring packages in the various hotspot destinations of Nepal. Besides, we also have been organizing hiking, jungle safari, river rafting, bungee jumping and mountain biking packages successfully throughout the popular destinations of Nepal. Since the inception, World Sight Journey has been proudly showcasing the scenic beauty of glorious Himalayas, the grandeur of incredibly diverse and wonderful Nepalese culture, amazingly rich flora and fauna, some yet-to-be discovered landscapes and many more to its valued clients from around the globe. We are so proud to showcase Nepal to the world.
trekking in Nepal, Trekking Company in Nepal, Everest base camp Trekking, Annapurna Base Camp Trekking, Upper Mustang Trekking , Peak Climbing in Nepal, Manaslu Circuit Trekking, Kanchenjunga Trekking, Island Peak Climbing

5:15 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

<< List
Jewish Bloggers
Join >>